
With an angelic, yet approachable voice and lyrics that cut to the core of topics like interpersonal relationships, queer desire, faith, and creativity, Lucy Dacus is one of the best current American singer-songwriters. She released her debut album No Burden in 2016 on Richmond, Virginia’s EggHunt label, and it was later re-released on indie giant Matador along with her subsequent two records Historian (2018 ; my personal favorite of Dacus’ discography) and Home Video (2021). In addition to her solo work, Lucy Dacus is a member of the supergroup Boygenius along with Phoebe Bridgers and MTSU alumna Julien Baker and won three Grammys in 2024 for her work with the group.
Dacus’ fourth album (and major label debut) Forever Is a Feeling comes out on Friday, March 28, 2025, so it’s as good a time as any to polish some gems from her back catalog.
In chronological order by release, here are the best six Lucy Dacus songs from the first decade of her career along with a companion playlist for your listening pleasure and images of Dacus from various periodicals in the CPM archive.

1. “Strange Torpedo”(2016 ; No Burden)
Lucy Dacus made quite the critical impression with her debut album No Burden, which was named the best album of 2016 by Philadelphia’s Magnet magazine beating out contemporary classics like Blackstar by David Bowie. “Strange Torpedo” is the standout track on the record. It features driving rhythm guitars and vocal runs from Dacus paired with lyrics that are a little gonzo while still having a memorable hook. Written from both first and second person POVs, the song explores Dacus’ relationship with someone who has made a lot of mistakes in their life potentially involving alcohol or substances. Despite these red flags, she’s inevitably drawn to them and the beautiful chaos they bring into her life. One of Lucy Dacus’ strengths as a songwriter is her use of interesting metaphors, and this track has that in spades.
2. “Night Shift” (2018 ; Historian)
A six-and-a-half-minute epic, “Night Shift” is arguably Lucy Dacus’ signature track and one of the best breakup songs of the past decade. It’s a slow burn of an album opener with solo electric guitar and a visceral first line, “The first time I tasted somebody else’s spit, I had a coughing fit” before burrowing into the tense postmortem of a romantic relationship. Dacus and her partner’s lives were so intertwined that she had to completely rearrange her schedule to avoid them. This is relatable to anyone who must avoid certain places because it reminds them too much of their ex. The build-up of the song from quiet and thoughtful to loud and wailing reflects the fight for closure in the lyrics culminating in the wry couplet, “In five years, I hope the songs feel like covers/Dedicated to new lovers”. This line shows that although romantic relationships might not last forever, powerful songs about one’s personal past have staying power and can even take on new meanings and contexts as an artist’s career progresses. Mirroring the slow build of the song itself, “Night Shift” didn’t get a music video until 2023. However, it was well worth the wait as I Saw the TV Glow helmer Jane Schoenbrun directed a Lynchian ode to queerness through the lens of Wizard of Oz with an appearance from Yellowjackets’ Jasmin Savoy Brown.

3. “Timefighter” (2018 ; Historian)
In addition to her vocal and lyrical chops, Lucy Dacus is a talented guitar player and was even recognized by Rolling Stone in 2023 as one of the 250 greatest guitarists of all time. Beginning with a plodding drum and bass intro, “Timefighter” transforms into a showcase of Dacus and her co-producer/live guitarist Jacob Blizard skillfully trading bluesy licks between verses and vocal lines. Towards the end of the track, they punch up the volume and the fuzz levels for an epic outro that feels like Lucy Dacus has put on some boxing gloves and is in a no holds barred tussle with the undefeated heavyweight champion of the world: death.
4. “VBS” (2021 ; Home Video)
Based on its title, visuals (The album art was photographed at the Byrd Theater in Lucy Dacus’ hometown of Richmond, Virginia.), and subject matter, Home Video is an album about Dacus’ youth and childhood that focuses on friendships, faith, compulsory heterosexuality, and trips to the local repertory movie theater. “VBS” clearly portrays Lucy Dacus’ Evangelical upbringing, and how seriously she took the lessons she learned about God and Jesus, Heaven and Hell while camping in the woods with T-shirt clad youth pastors and pre-teen boys. She wanted to “save” her boyfriend from the evils of snorting nutmeg at camp while he was dealing with much more serious personal issues at home and had to listen to high-volume heavy metal music to drown out his anxieties. (Dacus and Jacob Blizard really shred after that Slayer mention.) “VBS” looks at the pros and cons of religious faith from a very specific lens, and the drone of its guitars and continuous organ riff evoke late night existential crises about your purpose in the world.

5. “Thumbs” (2021 ; Home Video)
Initially an unreleased live song that Lucy Dacus begged audiences to not record, “Thumbs” is the bleeding heart of Home Video with lines like “I imagine my thumbs on the irises/Pressing in until they burst”. It describes a time when Dacus accompanied a friend to meet the friend’s absentee father, and in a 2021 Pitchfork interview, she said that writing the song made her “… feel weird, almost sick”. “Thumbs” has minimal instrumentation (Just keyboards played by Jacob Blizard.) to help you better process Lucy Dacus’ pleading lyrics about possibly killing her friend’s dad. However, this funeral dirge/revenge song about terrible fathers has a cathartic conclusion with Dacus filling verses with how much she admires her friend’s brilliance and resilience. In the end, “Thumbs” is a hymn to found family, a concept that resonates with many LGBTQ+ folks.
6. “Kissing Lessons” (2022 ; Non-album single)
“Kissing Lessons” is a sugary, short n’ sweet power pop song released as a single by Lucy Dacus between Home Video and her upcoming album Forever is a Feeling. The track is the story of the grade school friendship between Dacus and her crush/first kiss, Rachel. Its urgent pace captures those first butterflies in your stomach when you have romantic feelings for someone, but you don’t know why. By the end of its hummingbird life span, “Kissing Lessons” ends up being the proverbial young queer experience of liking someone but not knowing if they like you or your gender. However, it’s more sweet than sour and shows off Lucy Dacus’ rarely seen pop punk side.
Honorable Mentions:
“I Don’t Wanna Be Funny Anymore”, “My Mother and I”, “Pillar of Truth”, “Christine”
If you’re interested in learning more about Dacus’ work, we have information about her in various periodicals found in the CPM archive, including Magnet, Billboard, American Songwriter, and Rolling Stone. Also, her yearn-inducing March 17 interview with Amanda Petrusich of the New Yorker is one of the beautiful things I’ve read in 2025 so far.
What’s your favorite Lucy Dacus song? (Either solo or with Boygenius.) Feel free to chime in on our Facebook, Instagram, or Blue Sky pages.
-Logan Dalton
The views expressed in this blog are the staff member’s own and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Center for Popular Music and Middle Tennessee State University.